Cold Feet

Chapter 5 - His Other Man

Fuck, Luke cursed, standing with his pants down in his bathroom. The fucking kid ripped his ass and now he was bleeding from it. He hissed through his teeth as he applied some antiseptic ointment, hoping it would heal quickly.

He wondered what the hell he was going to do. He saw Lorelai half naked at her house with another guy and immediately ran into Dean, getting fondled and fucked in the ass as a result. And he liked it, a lot more than he wanted to admit. He couldn't exactly dump Lorelai for being with another man, they had agreed that they weren't exclusive. And even if he wanted to be all holier-than-thou, he had just fucked someone else. A male someone else..

"Oh my God, Luke!" He heard Lorelai shout, from behind his bed. Crap, how did she get in here?

"Lorelai!" he said, standing up, cupping himself with his hand.

"Luke, what are you doing?" she demanded, walking towards him.

"My, uh, it's, I'm bleeding, okay!" he explained, blushing.

"In your hrrmmm?"

"Yes! Dammit!"

"Let me see!" she insisted, trying to look behind him.

"No! Lorelai, we've only been seeing each other for a few weeks, I'm not going to let you see my, my, my--"

"Asshole!"

"Jeez!"

"Stop bitching and bend over."

Luke soon found himself bent over the bathroom sink with his not-quite-girlfriend inspecting his anus.

"Luke... this is..."

"Bleeding, yeah I know."

"No I mean, yeah, it's bleeding, but... what the hell have you been doing?" she demanded, panic in her voice. "And oh my God, there's cum on your collar!"

"Fuck!" Luke shouted, bending to lift his pants up. "Fuck! I didn't want you to know, I didn't want you to find out like this!"

"The-the person you're seeing, the person, it's a guy?" she asked, completely breathless. She backed slowly away from him until her calves hit his bed and she plopped down.

"Yeah," Luke admitted, beat red. "I'm sorry."

"Are you dumping me for him?" she asked, almost tearful.

"What?" he growled, "Why the fuck would I do that! I'm not gay!"

"Luke, I am so confused right now," she huffed, looking away.

"God dammit, let me change my shirt and I'll explain it as best as I can, okay?"

"Fine," she agreed, crossing her arms, unwilling to meet his eye.

Luke quickly removed the cum-stained shirt and grabbed a clean one from a hanger, but didn't bother to put it on over his t-shirt.

He grabbed the chair form his desk and dragged it over so he could sit in front of her. "Listen, it happened before we got together. Just a few days before... I'd never, I'd never been with a guy before. I don't... I don't look at men, okay! In fact, you're the only person I've really looked at for years!"

Lorelai lifted her eyes to meet his and smiled. "Then how did it happen?"

"I don't really know... I mean, he--he was attracted to me. And he... he touched me. And... I didn't stop him."

"How often?"

"What?" Luke asked, crossing his arms. "How many times have you fucked Jason since we've been together?"

"Luke!" she gasped, squinting her eyes shut. "Fine, twice. And I didn't want to either time, but he just showed up, and I found myself--I just gave in. I'm sorry."

Luke blushed and looked at his lap. "I saw you this morning, with the Jason guy on your porch. I saw you in your robe... and when I saw you kiss... I sort of lost it. I had avoided the guy, the one I'd been with, while we were dating, and we'd only, you know, twice before. But when I saw you, and then I saw... him, I sort of lost and let it happen."

"Oh," she breathed. "We didn't, I was about to get into the shower. He didn't even come in..."

"Fuck," Luke cursed, dropped his head in his hands. "I'm a fool."

"It's okay," Lorelai told him, leaning over and putting her hand on his knee. "I think I'm okay with it, you and the guy."

He lifted his head up, "You are?"

"I mean, you seem to enjoy being with him?" Lorelai said slowly, inspecting his reaction closely.

Luke blushed and dropped his gaze again. "It's not that I have feelings for the guy, it's just, it's just fucking."

"I understand."

Luke raised his eyes again and stared into her deep blues. "I'm going to stop it."

"No, Luke!" she responded, "I don't want you to!"

"What?" he asked, confused for the thousandth time by Lorelai Gilmore.

"I'm... I'm not ready," she told him, looking away and blushing.

"Fuck," he muttered. "Fine, I have to get back." He rose and walked towards the door.

"Luke," she said pleadingly as she stood. "Could you take a few more minutes?"

"Lorelai, I just got fucked in the ass by a guy, I don't think today is a good day me to turn around and fuck you too!" He shouted, cringing after he finished speaking and his words rang in his hears.

"Luke," she pleaded, desperation on her face.

"Fine," he grunted, advancing on her. "But I'm keeping my clothes on."

He pushed her back down onto his bed and pushed her skirt up around her waist. He groaned when he saw she had no panties on, but didn't waste time before putting his mouth on her clit.

"Fuck, Lorelai," he whispered, taking his mouth off of her for a second. "You're so fucking wet."

"Mmmm," Lorelai moaned, pushing Luke's hat from his head and placing her hands in his hair.

Luke continued to lick her sopping wet pussy, wondering if it had gotten like this when she thought about Luke with another guy. Experimentally, Luke shoved one finger into her tight entrance, and hooked it up to connect with her G-spot.

Lorelai lifted her head and emitted a soft, "Oh!" when he connected and fell back to urge him on. Luke inserted two more fingers easily inside of her, moving them in and out forcefully. He sucked her clitoris into his mouth and bit down on it lightly, flicking it with his tongue. This caused Lorelai to shout out and beg Luke to fuck her.

Luke just shook her head and shoved his finger deeper inside of her. "I won't," he told her, taking his mouth off of her. "I won't fuck you both in the same day."

"Oh, Luke," she gasped. "But you're so hard, always so hard for me!"

Luke lowered his head again and bit down on her clitoris, harder than before, to silence her. She moaned and pulled his head closer to her dripping vagina. Luke took his second hand that had just been supporting her butt and experimentally inserted it into her tight asshole.

Lorelai squeeked and raised her breasts in the air, shouting his name. Luke drove his finger deeper into her ass, his other hand hard into her opening and continued to suck hard on her clit. He felt her come forcefully on his fingers and felt like her contracting muscles almost broke his bones. He groaned when he thought about what his cock would have felt like in there, but brushed the thought away, lapping at her juices until she came down.