One NIght is Never Enough

‘Don’t freak out.’

Ellie was nervous. Sarah was taking out sex toys that were kind of scary to Ellie. Ellie didn’t consider herself to be a sexual prude but she had never used toys during sex. The kinkiest in the bedroom that she had ever got was blindfolds and tying up with scarves. Devon always liked that. Ellie was always more public sex type of girl. What she was looking at was like nothing she had ever seen. She recognized the dildos and the strap-ons even though they were not all the same. Some were large, one was double sided, and one had a sac looking object. The biggest strap-on looked to be as long as her forearm and about as wide. It also looked to have two shorter dildos on the harness that looked like they would they would go in the harness wearer. There are handcuffs that are covered in fake fur. There also looked to be nipple clamps. There were two of those even though one looked like it had an extra clamp. She recognized the Wartenberg wheel since she had to use it to test nerve reactions as a doctor though she doubts Sarah used it for the same thing. There was an egg shaped vibrator that she recognized from one of her college roommates used and it looked to have a remote with it.

The items that really were freaking Ellie out were the whips. There was a riding crop that Ellie doubted Sarah had for horse riding. Another of the whips looked like something for a lion. The last one was the cat o’nine tails. There were also a couple of ball gags that appeared to be attached to harnesses and a collar. Ellie wandered if Sarah used any of these on her brother. That was a thought Ellie wished she hadn’t thought of.

“You don’t have to be worried about anything. I’m not going to be using all of these on you unless you want me to.”
Sarah gave Ellie her most teasing smile. Ellie relaxed a little bit. She didn’t know what it was about Sarah that made Ellie want to do things that she would never do before.

“Actually, I was really looking for this.”

Ellie looked at what Sarah was holding and saw that that it was massage oil. Ellie gave Sarah a bright smile at this.

“Okay, get on the bed and lay down on your stomach.”

Ellie complied with Sarah’s request. She got on top of the bed and lay down on her stomach. She waited for about a minute but didn’t feel Sarah getting on the bed.

“Sarah?”

Ellie was about to get up and turn around but Sarah’s words stopped her.

“Stay there. Close your eyes and just relax. Trust me it will be worth it.”

Ellie closed her eyes and could hear Sarah moving about. After about a minute, Ellie felt the bed dip. Next thing she felt was a cool liquid dripping on her back. Her nose could pick up the scent of vanilla. Sarah was pouring a generous amount of the oil on Ellie’s back. Soon Sarah’s hands begin to rub the oil in. Ellie is amazed at the feeling of Sarah’s hands on her back. Her hands are firm yet not too rough. Sarah starts by massage around Ellie’s shoulders and her neck. Sarah is really rubbing the oil in deep. Whatever tension Ellie may have been feeling, they are melting away under Sarah’s skilled fingers. After a few minutes, Sarah’s hands began to rub lower down Ellie’s back. Ellie had started to moan under Sarah’s expert ministrations.

“Oh god Sarah that feels so good.”

Sarah leaned over and kissed Ellie’s lower back where her fingers had just been massaging.

“You haven’t felt anything yet.” Her hands return to Ellie’s lower back. Her thumbs seem to at first be focused on the base of her spine right above her butt. Sarah then moves her hands to the dimples on her lower back and starts massage them. Ellie was finding herself becoming increasingly wet. Actually wetter. Sarah than began to massage Ellie’s butt. Ellie tensed up a little with this especially when Sarah teased Ellie’s butt crack with her thumbs. However, Sarah then started to rub down Ellie’s legs. Soon, Ellie’s was oiled from top to bottom. Sarah though didn’t seem finish. She began to rub the inside of Ellie’s legs. They moved up till they reached the apex of Ellie’s legs.

“Oh shit.” Ellie moaned out when she felt Sarah rubbing her pussy. Ellie moved her body on her hands and knees so that she could push back. Ellie was getting a little frustrated by Sarah just rubbing her pussy with penetration. “Sarah, please!”

She swore she heard Sarah chuckle. She was going to start begging some more when she felt something penetrating her. It was smaller than the dildos. Ellie realized it was the egg-shaped vibrator. Sarah was pushing it in and out of Ellie’s pussy. Ellie was humping herself backwards to meet each thrust.

“Yes! Right there.” However, as soon as Ellie said this Sarah stopped. She kept the egg in Ellie’s pussy. Ellie then felt the vibrator turned on. Apparently, Sarah wasn’t going to fool around because it seemed to running on high. Ellie felt the vibrations throughout her body. “Holy shit!”

Soon Ellie was humping the air. Her pussy was filled with wonderful vibrations. The vibrations were so distracting that she thought nothing of her butt cheeks being pulled apart. However, she couldn’t ignore the feel of Sarah tongue on her asshole.

“Sarah, what…oh fuck!” Ellie couldn’t think of anything to say as Sarah’s tongue pushes into her asshole. No one had ever done this to her. Ellie had never allowed anyone to touch her asshole during sex. For some reason sex with Sarah was different. Not because it was another woman. Sarah wasn’t her first woman. She experimented in college. No, it’s just with Sarah; she was willing to do things she would never do. Hell, she never would have believed she would sleep with the woman her baby brother was in love with.

But the feeling of Sarah’s tongue in her ass was too good. Ellie never would have believed a tongue in her ass would ever feel this good. Sarah was jack hammering her tongue into Ellie’s ass. The sensation was amazing along with the vibrating egg in her pussy. Sarah reached down and began to rotate the egg in her pussy while pushing in and out.

“Oh god, please keep doing that! Yes, right there…I’m…Sarah!” Ellie felt her entire body explode with the most amazing feeling. She was moving faster and faster riding out her orgasm for all it was worth. “Uhnnnn!”

Ellie slumped forward as the orgasm subsided. Sarah stopped pushing the egg in and just left it in Ellie’s pussy. Sarah also stopped tonguing Ellie’s ass. However, Ellie realized the egg was still in her pussy and still turned on high.

“No… can’t…what the fuck?” Ellie looked back to see Sarah pushing a dildo into her ass. “Sarah, I’ve…”

“I know you’re an anal virgin. It turns me on so much. It makes me so hot to know that I’m going to be your first.”

Ellie could tell that Sarah was not going to take no for an answer. However, once Sarah started rub her clit, Ellie wasn’t going to try to stop her.

Sarah was gentle in her entry of Ellie’s ass. Inch by inch she pushed the strap on dildo into Ellie’s ass. She held firmly to Ellie’s hips with both hands. Ellie wasn’t sure what she was feeling. The vibrations in her pussy were creating so much wetness that is was dripping down her legs. There was also the sensation of her asshole expanding and being invaded. Sure Sarah’s fingers and tongue had been in her ass but they were nothing next to the fullness the dildo was creating. She had been on her hands and knees but ended to with head on the bed trying to breathe as more and more of the dildo entered her ass. The deeper it went the more difficult it seemed. She was about to say something but she was cut off by something liquid-like blasting in her ass. Ellie tensed up. That was not expected. It felt like the dildo ejaculated in her.

“Just relax. Just a little something to make it easier. Relax Ellie.” Sarah pulled back and allowed Ellie to relax. As soon as Ellie relaxed, Sarah pushed back in with more force. This time Sarah pushed the dildo all the way in. Her hips met Ellie’s ass.

“Holy shit. I feel so full.” Sarah held firmly onto Ellie’s hips as she began to fuck Ellie’s ass at a steadily harder pace. Ellie was starting to enjoy the feeling of the dildo in her ass. She rose up back to her hands and knees. She was now able to start pushing back to meet each thrust. With Ellie moving to meet each trust, Sarah moved her hands off Ellie’s hips. One hand reached up to start groping Ellie’s breasts. She twisted and pinched the nipples. The other hand rubbed Ellie’s clit. “Oh god I’m getting so close. Fuck!”

“Come on. Push that ass back!” Sarah rolled Ellie’s clit between her fingers before she pinched it.

“Fuck! I’m cumming!”

Sarah began to pick up the pace. She could feel her own orgasm approaching. She moved the hand rubbing Ellie’s clit and reached to pull out the vibrator. Sarah placed the vibrator against Ellie’s clit. The new sensation caused another even bigger eruption to go through Ellie’s body.

“Sarah!!!” Sarah kept pounding Ellie’s ass and held the vibrator on Ellie’s clit. Ellie felt her pussy clenching. Her orgasm was ongoing. She kept waiting for it to end but one orgasm followed another with no respite. Ellie became a puddle of orgasmic bliss. She was no longer able to form words but just grunting and moaning.

“Almost there! Alm…” Sarah felt her orgasm wash over her. “Ellie!”

Sarah gave a couple of more thrusts before emptying the rest of the sac in Ellie’s ass. Finally the two girls collapsed on the bed. Sarah turned off the vibrator before she gave it to Ellie. Ellie brought it to her mouth and cleaned it of her own juices. Sarah gently removed the dildo from Ellie’s ass. She removed the harness and tossed the strap-on to the side. Sarah curled behind Ellie and wrapped her arm around Ellie.

“Are you okay?”

“Yes, it feels a little funny with that liquid in my ass.”

Ellie yawned in exhaustion. Her eyelids were fluttering. It was not long before she fell asleep. Sarah watched as she did. She pleased with what had happened. She hadn’t expected it but now knew that she wanted to keep having sex with Ellie. She wanted to keep fucking her ass. She had taken Ellie’s last virginity. She had marked her territory. That thought helped Sarah relax and fall asleep.

A couple of hours later, Ellie was waking up. She looked around the unfamiliar surroundings. She remembered the night’s activities. She needed to go home. She freed herself from Sarah’s grasp and got out of bed. She started to look for her clothes when her eyes landed on one of the toys. An idea occurred to her.

‘Turnabout is only fair.’